Biden Administration’s Embrace of Indigenous Knowledge in Alaska Leases Sparks Controversy

Biden Administration’s Embrace of Indigenous Knowledge in Alaska Leases Sparks Controversy

  • February 19, 2024

Olalekan Adigun, BNN Breaking

In an unprecedented move that has stirred significant debate, the Biden administration’s decision to halt oil and gas leases in Alaska, citing the importance of ‘Indigenous Knowledge,’ has led to a formal scientific integrity complaint by Protect the Public’s Trust. At the heart of this contention is the administration’s approach of placing traditional wisdom on par with scientific evidence in its decision-making processes—a practice that, while aiming to honor and incorporate the insights of native peoples, is now under scrutiny for its adherence to scientific principles as governed by federal law.

The spotlight shines on Interior Secretary Deb Haaland, who has been instrumental in promoting the integration of ‘Indigenous Knowledge’ in federal policy decisions. This approach, however, has sparked a fierce debate over its compatibility with the Information Quality Act and other regulations that dictate the use of scientific evidence in federal decision-making. The complaint by Protect the Public’s Trust argues that this precedence of ‘spiritual wisdom’ over empirical science could not only undermine the integrity of governmental decisions but also render them susceptible to manipulation, raising questions about the balance between respecting indigenous perspectives and maintaining a commitment to scientific rigor.

Read more